Business woman using calculator and writing make note with calculate. Woman working at office with laptop and documents on his desk
Business woman using calculator and writing make note with calculate. Woman working at office with laptop and documents on his desk

Trust in the earn-out – especially in times of crisis!

10 jun 2020

“The earn-out won’t come anyway”- that is one of those sentences that M&A consultants hear a thousand times and yet they are always immediately startled. Why?  Because it means trouble. If the founder himself does not believe in his own business plan, how is the buyer supposed to? Recent surveys by the investment bank Carlsquare from more than 250 transactions between 2010 and today have shown that in the vast majority of cases, 82.1 percent of the earn-out is actually achieved if it has been agreed upon beforehand. On average, 89.2 percent of the initial payment was paid out as performance-based compensation, and even the median is still at 50 percent – a quite lucrative business for all parties involved.

So why are so many founders sceptical about the earn-out?

Although currently, during the crisis, the instruments of the earn-out alone make transactions possible in the first place – sale slumps and associated uncertainties regarding company valuation can be bridged well by an earn-out – quite a few founders still have doubts about this construct. The reason: sometimes the scepticism lies not in the lack of belief in the company’s goals, but in the fact that it is difficult to leave the fate of one’s own company in the hands of others. What if the new shareholder on board pursued other interests than those of actually making the purchased company even more successful? Perhaps he simply intended to keep unwelcome competitors quiet? What if he imposed unnecessary costs on him, thus limiting his success? What if he lost control of his house. What if that ruined the results?

Detect rotten eggs

There are quite effective solutions to these concerns. For example, through contractually agreed earn-out protection mechanisms. This refers in particular to veto rights of the minority shareholder for unbudgeted expenses, which can be used to prevent arbitrary additional costs that could jeopardise the earn-out. Furthermore, founders should refrain from buying prospective buyers who do not promise synergies or even expect negative effects on the business, for example due to channel conflicts. In addition, founders should obtain earn-out references from past business partners of the buyer.

The current crisis gives earn-out much more weight than it already has. This is because the seller does not want to sell on the basis of this year’s poor figures, while for the investor the results from 2019 only have historical value. The earn-out offers the opportunity to circumvent the risks and negative effects of the current situation and to make the deal possible despite a drop in sales.

Which maturities generate the most profitable earn-out?

If buyer and seller are in agreement in principle, the question arises as to what period of time the earn-out should be agreed upon at best. Our evaluations have shown that on average a period of 1.5 years is set. According to our figures, one-year earn-outs lead to a 30-50% higher initial payment compared to earn-outs lasting several years. However, after one year it reaches on average only a comparatively low 27% of the original price. All in all, the earn-out after one year is still a fairly safe bank.

Deals with two-year earn-outs were the weakest in the overall result. With a three-year term, sellers were able to get more out in year two and three in particular (59% vs. 35% earnout in total).

With a term of four years, there have been repeated cases, especially in recent years and in transactions in the “Consumer Internet” segment, in which the founders were even able to increase the initial purchase price tranche 3.5-fold.

Put/Call or earn-out?

This question can be answered, as the business economist says, decisively with: “That depends! An option can be structured very differently. As a rule, a multiple is agreed upon, to which the corresponding option can be drawn. This applies to both the buyer (call) and the seller (put). This is then multiplied, for example, by the last realised EBITDA. This is how the value of the option is calculated.

Earnouts are occasionally provided with progressive scales, through which it can be advantageous for the seller to “beat” the business plan. For the “sportsmen” among the founders, the earn-out solution can therefore be more attractive because there is a potentially greater chance of achieving a higher purchase price if it is not capped.

Factors why the earn-out is not achieved

With seven out of ten cases, the most common reason why the earn-out was not achieved is a clear business plan failure. In second place, in one out of five cases, the missed target was caused by the withdrawal of an important customer. Even if the M&A advisor takes a lot of pressure off the entrepreneur, 3 out of 20 companies justify the earn-out loss by citing an excessively resource-intensive M&A process, which caused too much damage to new business. Finally, one in 20 sellers lost the earn-out due to incorrect accounting and subsequent adjustments required by the auditors.

If there are justified doubts about the objectives, then either earn-out clauses should be waived or the initial price should be negotiated high enough so that the earn-out, should it come against all expectations, would only be a nice extra income instead of a calculated share of the purchase price.

What must be avoided at all costs in earn-out agreements

While not all of the above factors can be excluded, there are certain clauses that must be avoided at all costs in order to achieve the earn-out. These include objectives that management cannot influence itself, for example, achieving technological milestones in which the buyer must play a significant role. Rigid hurdles, where even a single euro of sales below target prevents the entire earn-out, should be replaced by much fairer, linearly scaled distributions.

Finally, founders should make sure to incorporate a right to push the earn-out. In the event of an unforeseeable recession such as the current Corona crisis, founders are then able to postpone the earn-out. Ultimately, a smart and healthy sale is all about creating a win-win situation for all partners. If the parties involved do not work together, if they do not have the same goal, the transaction will be a failure for both sides. One better be safe than sorry when selling a company. Perfect foresight is half the battle and timing is everything.

 

Team

Bild av Jessica Algner
Jessica Algner

Assistant

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47-12

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Polina Amini
Polina Amini

Senior Associate

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-14

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Jonatan Andersson
Jonatan Andersson

Equity Analyst

Telefon: +46 70 508 00 51

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Markus Augustsson
Markus Augustsson

Head of Equity Research

Telefon: +46 76 235 03 20

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Agata Barsallo
Agata Barsallo

Office Management & Accounting

Telefon: +44 20 8017 6020

@

Bild av Caroline Berglund
Caroline Berglund

Head of Equity Sales

Telefon: +46 73 382 10 82

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Anders Bo
Anders Bo

Managing Partner

Telefon: +45 4199 8252

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Ulf Boberg
Ulf Boberg

Senior Advisor Life Sciences

Telefon: +46 73 312 44 90

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Manfred Drax
Manfred Drax

Partner

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53-15

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Anders Elgemyr
Anders Elgemyr

Managing Partner

Telefon: +46 70 496 18 15

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Niklas Elmhammer
Niklas Elmhammer

Senior Equity Analyst

Telefon: +46 70 898 39 59

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Sebastian Fischer
Sebastian Fischer

Director

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53-12

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Daniel Garlipp
Daniel Garlipp

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-19

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Philip Goldhahn
Philip Goldhahn

Vice President

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-21

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Thorsten Grandt
Thorsten Grandt

Vice President

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47-20

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Johan Heigard
Johan Heigard

Vice President

Telefon: +46 70 246 99 88

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Caroline Heintz
Caroline Heintz

Senior Associate

Telefon: +46 707 40 68 58

@

Bild av Maurice Hinrichs
Maurice Hinrichs

Associate

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-20

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Arnold Holle
Arnold Holle

Managing Partner

Telefon: +44 20 80176020

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Lars Johansen
Lars Johansen

IT&Telecom Expert

@

Bild av Elaine Kelly
Elaine Kelly

Head of Marketing

Telefon: +49 40 300 836 18

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Anna-Lena Kickbusch
Anna-Lena Kickbusch

Office Management & Accounting

Telefon: +49 40 300 836 10

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Morten Kjærulff
Morten Kjærulff

Partner

Telefon: +45 2634 9031

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Mischa Krause
Mischa Krause

Director

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-24

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Steffen Leckert
Steffen Leckert

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53 26

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Malve Liebig
Malve Liebig

Senior Associate

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53-18

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Erik Lundberg
Erik Lundberg

Partner

Telefon: +46 73 850 35 59

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Eva Macha
Eva Macha

Office Management & PA to Michael Moritz

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47-10

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Mandy May
Mandy May

Head of Operations

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47 16

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Mirja Meyer
Mirja Meyer

Office Management & Accounting

Telefon: +49 40 300 836 10

@

Bild av Mark Miller
Mark Miller

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 40 300 836-11

LinkedInXING

@

Bild av Michael Moritz
Michael Moritz

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47-13

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Bertil Nilsson
Bertil Nilsson

Senior Equity Analyst

Telefon: +46 70 434 90 03

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Flemming C. Pedersen
Flemming C. Pedersen

Managing Partner

Telefon: +45 4199 8251

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Anika Schaefer
Anika Schaefer

Office Management & HR

Telefon: +49 89 255 495 310

@

Bild av Alexander Schleppegrel
Alexander Schleppegrel

Associate

Telefon: +45 2621 0543

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Nico Schmidt-Weidemann
Nico Schmidt-Weidemann

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53-17

@

Bild av Caspar Graf Stauffenberg
Caspar Graf Stauffenberg

Managing Partner

Telefon: +49 89 255 49 53-11

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Jon Tingling
Jon Tingling

Vice President

Telefon: +44 77 1347-8286

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Sybille de Vegvar
Sybille de Vegvar

Business Development

Telefon: +44 20 8017 6017

@

Bild av Oskar Wollert
Oskar Wollert

Vice President

Telefon: +46 761 71 11 60

@

Bild av Jan-Frederik Zapp
Jan-Frederik Zapp

Associate

Telefon: +49 30 8093347-31

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Nils Zettelmeyer
Nils Zettelmeyer

Director

Telefon: +49 30 809 33 47-25

LinkedIn

@

Bild av Andreas Zetzsche
Andreas Zetzsche

Partner

Telefon: +49 30 809 3347 33

@

Bild av Marta Zientarski
Marta Zientarski

Vice President

Telefon: +46 73 840 55 66

@